Welcome to Edugrown – Your Learning Partner EduGrown
🕑 Aaj 2 free content aur bacha hai. Login karein →
← Back to Study Content
NCERT Solution

Ch-9 Propositions and their Converses Class 9th Mathematics Ganita Manjari NCERT Solution

Class 9 · Mathematics (Ganita Manjari) · Ch-9 Propositions and their Converses · ENGLISH · 104 views

Ye material inke liye bhi hai: BIHAR BOARD CBSE CHHATTISGARH BOARD JHARKHAND BOARD MP BOARD NIOS RAJASTHAN BOARD UP BOARD
Advertisement

Class 9 · Ganita Manjari Part II

Chapter 9 — Propositions and their Converses

Complete solutions to every in-text question and all 17 questions of Exercise Set 9.1, explained step by step with counterexamples and full justifications.

8 In-text questions 17 Exercise questions Detailed proofs
Key idea of this chapter. A proposition is a statement that is either true or false. The converse of "if X then Y" is "if Y then X". A true proposition may have a false converse. To disprove a statement you only need one counterexample; to prove it you must cover every case.

In-text Questions (Think and Reflect & Examples)

Every question asked inside the chapter text, in the order it appears.

Think and Reflect · Page 1

Statement 1 (already proved earlier): If two sides of a triangle are equal, then the angles opposite the equal sides are equal.

Statement 2 is its converse: If two angles of a triangle are equal, then the sides opposite the equal angles have equal lengths. Is Statement 2 true? Can you prove it?

(Hint: Draw the altitude from the vertex containing the third angle.)

Solution

Yes, Statement 2 is true. Here is a complete proof using the hint.

Given In , . To prove: .
A B C D @edugrown
Altitude drawn from , the vertex containing the third angle
Draw the altitude Drop the perpendicular from onto . So .
Compare the two small triangles Look at and :
  •  (both are right angles, by construction)
  •  (this is the given )
  •  (the same side is shared by both triangles)
Apply the AAS congruence rule Two angles and a non-included side of one triangle equal the matching two angles and side of the other. Hence
Read off the matching sides Corresponding parts of congruent triangles are equal (CPCT). The side opposite in is ... but the side we want is the hypotenuse of each: in matches in . Therefore .
Answer Statement 2 is true. If then , so the sides opposite equal angles are equal. Here the proposition and its converse are both true.
Why the hint works. The altitude splits the one triangle into two triangles that share a side. That shared side is exactly the extra piece of information needed to turn "two equal angles" into a congruence.
Example 1 · Page 1

Proposition P: If it rains, then the road is wet.
Converse Q: If the road is wet, then it has rained.

Is the converse necessarily true?

Solution

P is true — rain falling on a road does make it wet.

Q need not be true. A wet road is evidence that some water reached it, but rain is not the only possible source of that water.

Counterexample A water tanker spills water on the road. The road is wet, but it has not rained. So "road is wet" happened while "it rained" did not — Q fails.

Other counterexamples: a municipal truck washing the street, a burst pipe, or someone watering a garden beside the road.

Answer P is True   Q is False. A single counterexample (the spilled tanker) is enough to settle it.
Definition to remember. A situation that shows a proposition is not always true is called a counterexample. One counterexample destroys a claim; no number of supporting examples can prove one.
Example 2 · Page 2

Proposition P: If a number is a multiple of 6, then it is a multiple of 3.
Converse Q: If a number is a multiple of 3, then it is a multiple of 6.

Justify why P is true. Then determine whether Q is true, and if not, give a counterexample.

Solution

Part 1 — Justifying P.

Write what "multiple of 6" means Let be a multiple of 6. Then there is a whole number with
Split 6 into its factors Since ,
Conclude is a whole number, so is 3 times a whole number — that is exactly what "multiple of 3" means. Hence P is true.
Now the converse Q If a number is a multiple of 3, must it be a multiple of 6?

The argument above used the fact that 3 is a factor of 6. Going backwards does not work, because a multiple of 3 need not also carry a factor of 2.

Counterexample Take .  , so 9 is a multiple of 3. But , which is not a whole number, so 9 is not a multiple of 6.

Other counterexamples: — in fact every odd multiple of 3 works.

Answer P is True   Q is False, with counterexample .
The pattern. A number is a multiple of 6 exactly when it is a multiple of both 3 and 2. Being a multiple of 3 alone is only half the requirement.
Example 3 + Discussion · Pages 2–3

Let be any positive integer.

Proposition P: If is a perfect square, then it has an odd number of factors.
Converse Q: If has an odd number of factors, then it is a perfect square.

Which of them are true? The chapter gives an argument about "factor–partner pairs". What does that argument prove — P or Q?

Solution

Both P and Q are true, but the argument in the text proves only Q. Let us see why, carefully.

Understand factor–partner pairs Every factor of has a partner , because . For the pairs are — and has factors, an even number.
Follow the chapter's chain of reasoning The text argues in this direction:
If no pair repeated, the factors could be matched off two-by-two and the total would be even. Since the total is odd, some pair must be — and then .
Identify what was proved The chain starts at "odd number of factors" and ends at "perfect square". That is precisely Q, not P. It says nothing about whether every square has an odd factor count.
Now prove P separately Start from (iii): . This immediately gives (ii) — the pair exists. But does (ii) give (i)? Not on its own: if there were two repeating pairs and , the count would come out even.
Close the gap A positive integer cannot have two different repeating pairs, because and force (for positive numbers). So there is exactly one repeating pair. All the other factors pair off evenly, and the single leftover makes the total odd. Hence P is true.
FactorsHow manySquare?
121, 2, 3, 4, 6, 126 (even)No
161, 2, 4, 8, 165 (odd)Yes,
251, 5, 253 (odd)Yes,
361, 2, 3, 4, 6, 9, 12, 18, 369 (odd)Yes,
Answer The chapter's factor-partner argument proves Q only. Both P and Q are in fact True, so here " is a perfect square" and " has an odd number of factors" imply each other.
Lesson. Read the direction of an argument carefully. Arrows that point from (i) to (iii) do not automatically point back from (iii) to (i).
Example 4 · Page 3

Proposition P: If two triangles have the same area, then they are congruent.
Converse Q: If two triangles are congruent, then they have the same area.

Determine whether each is true. Justify the true ones and give a counterexample for each false one.

Solution

P is false. Q is true.

Test P with a counterexample Area of a triangle is . Many different base–height pairs give the same product.
base = 12 cm h = 10 base = 24 cm h = 5 Area = 60 cm² Area = 60 cm² @edugrown
Equal areas, completely different shapes — so equal area does not force congruence
Counterexample to P Triangle 1: base cm, height cm area cm².
Triangle 2: base cm, height cm area cm².
Same area, but their sides are different lengths, so they are not congruent.
Prove Q If two triangles are congruent, one can be placed exactly on top of the other — every side and every angle matches. In particular their bases are equal and their corresponding heights are equal, so
Congruent figures occupy the same amount of space, so they must have the same area. Q is true.
Answer P is False (counterexample above)  ·  Q is True.
Takeaway. Congruence is a much stronger condition than equal area. Equal area is just one consequence of congruence, not a replacement for it.
Think and Reflect · Page 3

It can also happen that both a proposition and its converse are false. Can you give an example?

Solution

We need a pair where each direction fails. Here are three clean examples.

Example from number theory P: If is odd, then is prime.
Counterexample to P: is odd but is composite.
Q (converse): If is prime, then is odd.
Counterexample to Q: is prime but even.
Example from geometry P: If a quadrilateral has two equal sides, then it is a parallelogram.
Counterexample to P: A kite has two pairs of equal adjacent sides but is not a parallelogram.
Q: If a quadrilateral is a parallelogram, then it has exactly two equal sides.
Counterexample to Q: A rhombus is a parallelogram with all four sides equal, not exactly two.
Example from daily life P: If a person is tall, then that person plays basketball.
Counterexample: Plenty of tall people have never touched a basketball.
Q: If a person plays basketball, then that person is tall.
Counterexample: Many excellent short basketball players exist.
Answer Yes. One simple pair: "If is odd then is prime" (false: ) and its converse "If is prime then is odd" (false: ). Both are false.
Example 5 · Page 4

Baudhāyana–Pythagoras theorem: Let be the side lengths of a triangle. If the triangle is right-angled, then .

(a) What is its converse?  (b) Is the converse true? Along the way: what can we say about the length of , and what can we say about and ?

Solution
Write the converse Keep the opening sentence as it is and swap the "if" and "then" parts of the second sentence:
Converse Let be the side lengths of a triangle. If , then the triangle is right-angled.
Set up the proof Let have sides with . We do not yet know it is right-angled — that is what we must show.
Triangle ABC with sides a, b and c
with — is it right-angled?
Construct a helper triangle Build a new right triangle with the right angle at and perpendicular sides and . This triangle is right-angled by construction.
Right triangle XYZ with perpendicular sides a and b
built with a right angle at , legs and
Find using the original theorem is right-angled, so the Baudhāyana–Pythagoras theorem applies to it:
But we were given , so , and since lengths are positive,
Compare the two triangles using SSS Now match them side by side:
  •  (just proved)
All three pairs of sides are equal, so by the SSS criterion,
Transfer the right angle Congruent triangles have equal corresponding angles (CPCT). Since , the matching angle in is also . So was right-angled all along.
Answer , and by SSS. The converse of the Baudhāyana–Pythagoras theorem is True. Theorem and converse are both true.
Why this is useful. The converse is what lets you check for a right angle by measuring. A triangle satisfies , so masons and carpenters use a 3-4-5 rope to lay out perfect right angles.
Think and Reflect · Page 5

1. Identify real-life examples in which a proposition is true but not its converse. Give nice counterexamples.

2. Give more examples from geometry as well as number theory in which a proposition is true but not its converse, with appropriate counterexamples.

Solution

Part 1 — Real-life examples

Proposition P (true)Converse Q (false)Counterexample to Q
If a creature is a dog, then it is a mammal.If a creature is a mammal, then it is a dog.A cow is a mammal but not a dog.
If today is Republic Day, then today is in January.If today is in January, then it is Republic Day.5 January is in January but is not Republic Day.
If I am in Bhopal, then I am in Madhya Pradesh.If I am in Madhya Pradesh, then I am in Bhopal.Indore is in MP but is not Bhopal.
If a fruit is a mango, then it has a seed.If a fruit has a seed, then it is a mango.An apple has seeds but is not a mango.
If the fan is switched on, then there is electricity.If there is electricity, then the fan is switched on.Power can be on while every fan is off.
The pattern behind all of these. Whenever one category sits inside a bigger category, "small big" is true and "big small" is false. Every counterexample is just a member of the bigger category that is outside the smaller one.

Part 2(a) — Geometry examples

Proposition P (true)Converse Q (false)Counterexample to Q
If a figure is a square, then it is a rectangle.If a figure is a rectangle, then it is a square.A rectangle is not a square.
If a quadrilateral is a rhombus, then its diagonals are perpendicular.If the diagonals of a quadrilateral are perpendicular, then it is a rhombus.A kite has perpendicular diagonals but unequal sides.
If two triangles are congruent, then they are similar.If two triangles are similar, then they are congruent.Triangles with sides and are similar but not congruent.
If two angles are vertically opposite, then they are equal.If two angles are equal, then they are vertically opposite.The two base angles of an isosceles triangle are equal but not vertically opposite.

Part 2(b) — Number theory examples

Proposition P (true)Converse Q (false)Counterexample to Q
If ends in 0, then is divisible by 5.If is divisible by 5, then ends in 0. is divisible by 5 but ends in 5.
If is divisible by 9, then is divisible by 3.If is divisible by 3, then is divisible by 9. is divisible by 3 but not by 9.
If is a multiple of 10, then is even.If is even, then is a multiple of 10. is even but not a multiple of 10.
If is prime, then is odd.If is odd, then is prime. is odd but .
Answer Any entry from the three tables above is a valid answer. The reliable recipe: pick a special case and a general case that contains it, then find a member of the general case that is not special.

Exercise Set 9.1 — Complete Solutions

For Questions 1–12: frame the converse, decide whether each statement is true, justify the true ones and give a counterexample for each false one.

Question 1

If two lines are parallel, then the corresponding angles formed by a transversal are equal.

Solution
Converse If the corresponding angles formed by a transversal are equal, then the two lines are parallel.
x y ℓ₁ ℓ₂ transversal @edugrown
Corresponding angles and sit in matching positions at the two crossings
Why the proposition is true This is the standard corresponding-angles result for parallel lines. If , slide the whole picture along the transversal until the first crossing lands exactly on the second. Because the lines never get closer or farther apart, the figure at the first crossing matches the figure at the second exactly, so .
Why the converse is also true Suppose but the lines are not parallel. Then they meet at some point , forming a triangle with the transversal. In that triangle, is an exterior angle and is the opposite interior angle. An exterior angle equals the sum of the two remote interior angles, so
An angle of means the lines never actually cross — a contradiction. Hence the lines must be parallel.
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse True. Both hold, so "parallel lines" and "equal corresponding angles" mean the same thing. This is exactly why the converse is used as the standard test for parallelism.
Question 2

If a quadrilateral is a square, then all its angles are equal.

Solution
Converse If all the angles of a quadrilateral are equal, then it is a square.
Proposition is true By definition a square has four right angles, so all four angles equal . They are certainly all equal.
Test the converse Let all four angles be . The angles of any quadrilateral add to , so
So "all angles equal" only tells us every angle is a right angle — it says nothing about the side lengths.
6 cm 2 cm All angles = 90°, but not a square @edugrown
A rectangle — equal angles, unequal sides
Counterexample A rectangle measuring cm by cm has all four angles equal to , but its sides are not all equal, so it is not a square.
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse False. Counterexample: any non-square rectangle. To force a square you need equal angles and equal sides.
Question 3 ★ (challenge)

Given any , bisect the angles at and . The bisectors meet at the incentre . Extend the bisectors beyond until they meet the opposite sides at and respectively.

Proposition: If , then .

Solution
Triangle ABC with angle bisectors from B and C meeting at incentre I and extended to E and F
Fig. 9.1 — the bisector from reaches on ; the bisector from reaches on
Converse If , then .

Part 1 — The proposition is TRUE.

Use the symmetry of an isosceles triangle Suppose . Then is isosceles and its axis of symmetry is the angle bisector drawn from , which passes through the incentre .
Reflect the whole figure in that axis Reflection in this axis maps and , and leaves and fixed. Since , the bisector from maps exactly onto the bisector from .
Follow where and go The bisector from meets at ; its mirror image, the bisector from , meets at . So the reflection sends . Reflection preserves distance and is fixed, therefore

Part 2 — The converse is FALSE.

Find the real condition for Let , , , and let be the inradius. A short calculation (shown in the note below) gives
So exactly when , which happens when either
Exploit the second possibility The second case gives with no requirement that . Any triangle with works.
Counterexample Take . Then and , and since we get .
But , so — the triangle is scalene. The converse fails.
A neat geometric reason for the case When , the angle (vertically opposite ) equals . Then
so quadrilateral is cyclic. Since bisects , the equal angles subtend the chords and . Equal inscribed angles subtend equal chords, so .
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse False.
holds whenever or . A triangle with angles has yet .
Where the formula comes from. In : and . The sine rule gives . Also from the right triangle formed by , and the touch point on . Substituting gives .
Question 4

If , then , where , and are any three numbers.

Solution
Converse If , then , where , and are any three numbers.
Proposition is true If then and are the same number written two ways. Adding the same to the same number gives the same result:
Converse is also true Start from and add to both sides:
This works for every number because every number has an additive inverse .
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse True.
Why this matters in equation solving. Solving uses the proposition to add to both sides, and uses the converse to be sure the new equation has exactly the same solutions as the old one. Both directions true means no solutions are gained or lost.
Question 5

If and are perfect squares, then is a perfect square.

Solution
Converse If is a perfect square, then and are perfect squares.
Prove the proposition Let and for whole numbers and . Then
Since is a whole number, is the square of a whole number. True.
Test the converse The converse claims that the only way to build a square by multiplying is from two squares. But two non-squares can supply each other's missing factors.
Counterexample , . Then is a perfect square, yet neither nor is a perfect square.

More counterexamples: ,  ,  ,  .

Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse False. Counterexample: .
Question 6

and are real numbers. If , then .

Solution
Converse If , then (for real numbers and ).
Proposition is true If , multiply both sides by the equal quantities:
Test the converse Squaring destroys the sign, because a negative number squared gives a positive result. Factorising shows this directly:
So either or . The second branch breaks the converse.
Counterexample , . Then and , so , but .
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse False. Counterexample: .
The correct conclusion from is , i.e. .
Watch out. This is exactly why squaring both sides of an equation can create extra (extraneous) roots — you must always check your answers back in the original equation.
Question 7

and are real numbers. If , then .

Solution
Converse If , then (for real numbers and ).
Proposition is true If , multiplying the same number by itself three times gives the same result: .
Converse — factorise the difference of cubes
Show the second factor cannot be zero (unless both are zero) Complete the square on :
Both terms are squares, so the sum is , and it equals only when and , i.e. .
Conclude If and are not both zero, the second factor is strictly positive, so , giving . And if both are zero, anyway. The converse is true.
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse True. Both hold.
Compare with Q6. Cubing keeps the sign (, not ), so no two different real numbers share a cube. Squaring loses the sign, which is why Q6's converse fails but Q7's does not.
Question 8

is a positive integer. If is divisible by 24, then it is divisible by both 4 and 6.

Solution
Converse If is divisible by both 4 and 6, then it is divisible by 24.
Proposition is true Let . Since ,
Both and are whole numbers, so is divisible by 4 and by 6. True.
Find the real consequence of "divisible by 4 and 6" A number divisible by both 4 and 6 must be a multiple of their LCM, not their product:
Since , the converse should fail.
Counterexample .   ✓ and ✓, but ✗.
Others: , , — every odd multiple of 12.
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse False. Counterexample . The reason is , not — the factor 2 is shared by 4 and 6 and gets counted twice in the product.
Question 9

is a positive integer. If is divisible by 60, then it is divisible by both 5 and 12.

Solution
Converse If is divisible by both 5 and 12, then it is divisible by 60.
Proposition is true . If then and , so is divisible by both. True.
Check whether the converse can fail Compare with Q8. There, 4 and 6 shared a common factor. Here:
They share no prime factor, i.e. — they are coprime.
Compute the LCM For coprime numbers the LCM is the full product:
So any divisible by both 5 and 12 is a multiple of 60. The converse is true.
Spell out the argument If and , write . Since and 5 shares no factor with 12, we must have , say . Then . ✓
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse True.
Compare Q8 and Q9. Splitting 's divisor into two parts works in both directions only when the two parts are coprime. fails (they share 2); works (they share nothing).
Question 10

is a positive integer. If is the square of a prime number, then it has exactly 3 factors.

Solution
Converse If has exactly 3 factors, then is the square of a prime number.
Prove the proposition Let with prime. Any factor of is built only from copies of , so the complete list is
These are three different numbers because . So has exactly 3 factors. True.
Prime FactorsCount
241, 2, 43
391, 3, 93
5251, 5, 253
7491, 7, 493
Prove the converse Suppose has exactly 3 factors. Since and are always factors and there are three in all, and the factor list is with .
Show must be prime If had a factor with , then would also divide , giving a fourth factor. That is impossible, so is prime.
Show is a factor of . It cannot be (that would make ), and it cannot be (that would make ). So the only option left in the list is , giving
The converse is true.
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse True. Having exactly 3 factors and being the square of a prime are the same condition.
Question 11

is a positive integer. If is a product of two unequal prime numbers, then it has exactly 4 divisors.

Solution
Converse If has exactly 4 divisors, then is a product of two unequal prime numbers.
Prove the proposition Let with , both prime. Its divisors are
All four are different: is given, both exceed , and both are less than . So exactly 4 divisors. True. (Example: has divisors .)
Test the converse — look for another shape with 4 divisors Ask what else could produce exactly four divisors. A cube of a prime does it:
Counterexample . Its divisors are — exactly 4. But is not a product of two unequal primes (it is ).
Also with divisors , and with divisors .
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse False. Counterexample .
Exactly 4 divisors means (unequal primes) or .
Handy rule. If , the number of divisors is . To get you need (two primes to power 1) or (one prime to power 3) — exactly the two cases above.
Question 12

is a positive integer. If and have no factors in common, then is not a multiple of 3.

Solution

Here "no factors in common" means no common factor other than , i.e. .

Converse If is not a multiple of 3, then and have no factors in common.
Prove the proposition using its contrapositive Instead of proving "no common factor not a multiple of 3", prove the equivalent statement "is a multiple of 3 there is a common factor".
Do it Suppose . Then
So divides both and — they share the factor 3. This contradicts "no factors in common". Hence if they share no factor, cannot be a multiple of 3. True.
Prove the converse Let be any common factor of and . Then divides their difference:
Rule out If then , making a multiple of 3 — but we assumed it is not. So is the only possibility, meaning and have no common factor. The converse is true.
Multiple of 3?Common factor
69Yes3
912Yes3
710Nonone (gcd = 1)
811Nonone (gcd = 1)
1013Nonone (gcd = 1)
Answer Proposition True  ·  Converse True. The two statements imply each other.
Question 13

There are no known "neat" expressions that generate only primes. Find counterexamples to the following claims.

(i) All numbers of the form are prime.
(ii) All numbers of the form are prime.
(iii) All numbers of the form are prime.

Solution

For each one we simply substitute until the result factorises.

(i)

Prime?
1Prime
2Prime
3Prime
4Composite —
Counterexample (i) gives , which is not prime.

(ii)

Prime?
1Prime
2Prime
5Prime
9Prime
10Composite —
Counterexample (ii) gives , which is not prime.
A shortcut worth seeing. Put : then . Whenever is a multiple of 11, every term carries a factor 11, so the value can never be prime. is a counterexample you can spot without any arithmetic.

(iii)

Prime?
1Prime
2Prime
3Prime
4Composite —
Counterexample (iii) gives , which is not prime. (Also : .)
Answer (i)  ·  (ii)  ·  (iii) .
All three claims are False.
Question 14

Find counterexamples to the following statements.

(i) If is a prime number, then is a prime number.
(ii) If is an even number, then is a prime number.

Solution

(i) prime prime

Test the primes in order
prime Prime?
2Prime
3Prime
5Prime
7Prime
11Composite —
Counterexample (i) is prime, but is not prime. (Check: ✓)

(ii) even prime

Test the even numbers in order
even Prime?
2Prime
4Prime
6Composite —
Counterexample (ii) is even, but is not prime. (Also : .)
Answer (i) :  .  ·  (ii) :  .
Both statements are False.
Background. Numbers of the form are called Mersenne numbers, and gives Fermat-type numbers. Both often give primes, which is exactly what makes them tempting — and exactly why mathematicians insist on proof rather than pattern-spotting.
Question 15

Consider the statement: "If a number is divisible by 8, then it is divisible by both 2 and 4".

(i) Justify the statement.
(ii) To check whether a given number is divisible by 8, is it enough to check whether it is divisible by 2 and 4? Why or why not?

Solution

(i) Justification

Start from the definition Let be divisible by 8, so for some integer .
Factor 8 in two useful ways
Since and are integers, is divisible by 2 and divisible by 4. The statement is true.

(ii) Is checking 2 and 4 enough?

This is asking about the converse Using the test would mean relying on: "if divisible by 2 and 4, then divisible by 8". That is the converse, and we must check it separately.
Find what divisibility by 2 and 4 actually guarantees
Since is already a factor of , the condition "divisible by 2 and 4" collapses to just "divisible by 4". It cannot reach 8.
Counterexample : divisible by 2 ✓, divisible by 4 ✓, but ✗.
Also — every number of the form .
State the correct test The working shortcut for 8 is: a number is divisible by 8 exactly when the number formed by its last three digits is divisible by 8. For example : the last three digits give ✓, so is divisible by 8.
Answer (i) True, since .
(ii) No, it is not enough. Checking 2 and 4 only confirms divisibility by . Counterexample: passes both tests but is not divisible by 8. Use the last-three-digits rule instead.
Question 16

A shortcut to check whether a given number is divisible by 3 is to add the digits of the number and check if the sum is a multiple of 3. Express the relationship between "a number is divisible by 3" and "sum of the digits is a multiple of 3" using "if–then" sentences.

Solution
Write the proposition
Proposition P If a number is divisible by 3, then the sum of its digits is a multiple of 3.
Write the converse
Converse Q If the sum of the digits of a number is a multiple of 3, then the number is divisible by 3.
Note that both are true Q is the one the shortcut actually uses: you add the digits, and if the sum is a multiple of 3 you conclude the number is divisible by 3. P is what guarantees the shortcut never misses a multiple of 3.
Why both hold — the idea behind the rule Take a 3-digit number . Split each place value:
is always a multiple of 3. So the number is a multiple of 3 exactly when is — both directions at once.
NumberDigit sumSum ÷ 3?Number ÷ 3?
471YesYes ()
5 238YesYes ()
124NoNo
Answer P: If a number is divisible by 3, then the sum of its digits is a multiple of 3. True
Q (converse): If the sum of the digits of a number is a multiple of 3, then the number is divisible by 3. True
Since both hold, the two statements imply each other — which is precisely what makes the shortcut a valid test.
Important. A shortcut is only trustworthy when both directions are true. Compare Q15, where only one direction held, so "check 2 and 4" was not a valid test for 8.
Question 17

Suppose we have identified a category of quadrilaterals called , and we must construct a quadrilateral of this type using two thin sticks placed as its diagonals, so that joining their endpoints gives a quadrilateral of type (see Fig. 9.2).

(i) Suppose satisfies: If a quadrilateral is of type , then it has equal-length diagonals.
  (a) Should the two sticks be of equal length? Why or why not?
  (b) Will it matter how the two sticks are put together?

(ii) Instead, suppose satisfies: If a quadrilateral has equal diagonals, then it is of type . What will be your answers to (a) and (b) now?

Solution
Two sticks placed as the diagonals of a quadrilateral, endpoints joined
Fig. 9.2 — the sticks are the diagonals; joining their four endpoints makes the quadrilateral

The whole question turns on which direction the given "if–then" runs.

Part (i):  type equal diagonals

Read what this tells you Equal diagonals is a necessary condition — every type- quadrilateral must have it. But it is not stated to be sufficient: having equal diagonals does not promise type .
(a) Should the sticks be equal? Yes, they must be. The sticks become the diagonals. If they were unequal, the quadrilateral would have unequal diagonals, and by the given statement it could not be of type . So equal sticks are required — but they do not guarantee success.
(b) Does the arrangement matter? Yes, very much. Because the condition is only necessary, two equal sticks can still be placed so that the result is not of type — the crossing angle and the point at which they cross both change the shape. Think of two equal sticks crossing at their midpoints at (a square) versus crossing at a slant or off-centre (various non-squares, all with equal diagonals). You must keep adjusting until the shape really is of type , and it may not be possible at all.

Part (ii):  equal diagonals type

Read what this tells you Now equal diagonals is a sufficient condition — producing it is enough to guarantee type .
(a) Should the sticks be equal? Yes — and now this is the whole job. Equal diagonals immediately forces the quadrilateral to be of type , so choosing two equal sticks guarantees success.
(b) Does the arrangement matter? No. However you cross two equal sticks, the resulting quadrilateral has equal diagonals, and by the given statement it is therefore of type . (The only practical care needed is that the sticks actually cross, so the four endpoints really do form a quadrilateral.)
Given statementEqual sticks?Arrangement matters?
(i) type equal diagonals  (necessary)Yes — required, but not enoughYes — may still fail
(ii) equal diagonals type  (sufficient)Yes — and it is enoughNo — any arrangement works
Answer (i) (a) Yes, equal sticks are necessary, but they do not guarantee type . (b) Yes, the arrangement matters — you may still end up with a quadrilateral that is not of type .
(ii) (a) Yes, and equal sticks are now enough to guarantee type . (b) No, the arrangement does not matter — any crossing of two equal sticks gives a type- quadrilateral.
The big lesson of this chapter. "" tells you is necessary for . "" tells you is sufficient for . Necessary conditions tell you what you cannot avoid; sufficient conditions tell you what is enough to finish the job.
Advertisement

💬 Comments & Doubts

💭

Abhi tak koi comment nahi

Sabse pehle comment karne wale bano!

Apna comment likhein

Doubt ho ya suggestion — kuch bhi poochh sakte hain. Login zaroori nahi hai.

19 + 4 =

Ye sirf ye confirm karne ke liye hai ki aap robot nahi hain.

Comment publish hone se pehle admin check karta hai.

🔒 Content copy nahi kar sakte