Class 9 · Ganita Manjari Part II
Chapter 9 — Propositions and their Converses
Complete solutions to every in-text question and all 17 questions of Exercise Set 9.1, explained step by step with counterexamples and full justifications.
In-text Questions (Think and Reflect & Examples)
Every question asked inside the chapter text, in the order it appears.
Statement 1 (already proved earlier): If two sides of a triangle are equal, then the angles opposite the equal sides are equal.
Statement 2 is its converse: If two angles of a triangle are equal, then the sides opposite the equal angles have equal lengths. Is Statement 2 true? Can you prove it?
(Hint: Draw the altitude from the vertex containing the third angle.)
Yes, Statement 2 is true. Here is a complete proof using the hint.
- ∠ADB=∠ADC=90∘ (both are right angles, by construction)
- ∠ABD=∠ACD (this is the given ∠B=∠C)
- AD=AD (the same side is shared by both triangles)
Proposition P: If it rains, then the road is wet.
Converse Q: If the road is wet, then it has rained.
Is the converse necessarily true?
P is true — rain falling on a road does make it wet.
Q need not be true. A wet road is evidence that some water reached it, but rain is not the only possible source of that water.
Other counterexamples: a municipal truck washing the street, a burst pipe, or someone watering a garden beside the road.
Proposition P: If a number is a multiple of 6, then it is a multiple of 3.
Converse Q: If a number is a multiple of 3, then it is a multiple of 6.
Justify why P is true. Then determine whether Q is true, and if not, give a counterexample.
Part 1 — Justifying P.
The argument above used the fact that 3 is a factor of 6. Going backwards does not work, because a multiple of 3 need not also carry a factor of 2.
Other counterexamples: 3, 15, 21, 27, 33 — in fact every odd multiple of 3 works.
Let n be any positive integer.
Proposition P: If n is a perfect square, then it has an odd number of factors.
Converse Q: If n has an odd number of factors, then it is a perfect square.
Which of them are true? The chapter gives an argument about "factor–partner pairs". What does that argument prove — P or Q?
Both P and Q are true, but the argument in the text proves only Q. Let us see why, carefully.
| n | Factors | How many | Square? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 12 | 6 (even) | No |
| 16 | 1, 2, 4, 8, 16 | 5 (odd) | Yes, 42 |
| 25 | 1, 5, 25 | 3 (odd) | Yes, 52 |
| 36 | 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 9, 12, 18, 36 | 9 (odd) | Yes, 62 |
Proposition P: If two triangles have the same area, then they are congruent.
Converse Q: If two triangles are congruent, then they have the same area.
Determine whether each is true. Justify the true ones and give a counterexample for each false one.
P is false. Q is true.
Triangle 2: base 24 cm, height 5 cm ⇒ area =21(24)(5)=60 cm².
Same area, but their sides are different lengths, so they are not congruent.
It can also happen that both a proposition and its converse are false. Can you give an example?
We need a pair where each direction fails. Here are three clean examples.
Counterexample to P: n=9 is odd but 9=3×3 is composite.
Q (converse): If n is prime, then n is odd.
Counterexample to Q: n=2 is prime but even.
Counterexample to P: A kite has two pairs of equal adjacent sides but is not a parallelogram.
Q: If a quadrilateral is a parallelogram, then it has exactly two equal sides.
Counterexample to Q: A rhombus is a parallelogram with all four sides equal, not exactly two.
Counterexample: Plenty of tall people have never touched a basketball.
Q: If a person plays basketball, then that person is tall.
Counterexample: Many excellent short basketball players exist.
Baudhāyana–Pythagoras theorem: Let a,b,c be the side lengths of a triangle. If the triangle is right-angled, then a2+b2=c2.
(a) What is its converse? (b) Is the converse true? Along the way: what can we say about the length of XY, and what can we say about △ABC and △XYZ?
- BC=a=YZ
- AC=b=XZ
- AB=c=XY (just proved)
1. Identify real-life examples in which a proposition is true but not its converse. Give nice counterexamples.
2. Give more examples from geometry as well as number theory in which a proposition is true but not its converse, with appropriate counterexamples.
Part 1 — Real-life examples
| Proposition P (true) | Converse Q (false) | Counterexample to Q |
|---|---|---|
| If a creature is a dog, then it is a mammal. | If a creature is a mammal, then it is a dog. | A cow is a mammal but not a dog. |
| If today is Republic Day, then today is in January. | If today is in January, then it is Republic Day. | 5 January is in January but is not Republic Day. |
| If I am in Bhopal, then I am in Madhya Pradesh. | If I am in Madhya Pradesh, then I am in Bhopal. | Indore is in MP but is not Bhopal. |
| If a fruit is a mango, then it has a seed. | If a fruit has a seed, then it is a mango. | An apple has seeds but is not a mango. |
| If the fan is switched on, then there is electricity. | If there is electricity, then the fan is switched on. | Power can be on while every fan is off. |
Part 2(a) — Geometry examples
| Proposition P (true) | Converse Q (false) | Counterexample to Q |
|---|---|---|
| If a figure is a square, then it is a rectangle. | If a figure is a rectangle, then it is a square. | A 2×5 rectangle is not a square. |
| If a quadrilateral is a rhombus, then its diagonals are perpendicular. | If the diagonals of a quadrilateral are perpendicular, then it is a rhombus. | A kite has perpendicular diagonals but unequal sides. |
| If two triangles are congruent, then they are similar. | If two triangles are similar, then they are congruent. | Triangles with sides 3,4,5 and 6,8,10 are similar but not congruent. |
| If two angles are vertically opposite, then they are equal. | If two angles are equal, then they are vertically opposite. | The two base angles of an isosceles triangle are equal but not vertically opposite. |
Part 2(b) — Number theory examples
| Proposition P (true) | Converse Q (false) | Counterexample to Q |
|---|---|---|
| If n ends in 0, then n is divisible by 5. | If n is divisible by 5, then n ends in 0. | 15 is divisible by 5 but ends in 5. |
| If n is divisible by 9, then n is divisible by 3. | If n is divisible by 3, then n is divisible by 9. | 6 is divisible by 3 but not by 9. |
| If n is a multiple of 10, then n is even. | If n is even, then n is a multiple of 10. | 4 is even but not a multiple of 10. |
| If n>3 is prime, then n is odd. | If n>3 is odd, then n is prime. | 9 is odd but 9=3×3. |
Exercise Set 9.1 — Complete Solutions
For Questions 1–12: frame the converse, decide whether each statement is true, justify the true ones and give a counterexample for each false one.
If two lines are parallel, then the corresponding angles formed by a transversal are equal.
If a quadrilateral is a square, then all its angles are equal.
Given any △ABC, bisect the angles at B and C. The bisectors meet at the incentre I. Extend the bisectors beyond I until they meet the opposite sides at E and F respectively.
Proposition: If AB=AC, then IE=IF.
Part 1 — The proposition is TRUE.
Part 2 — The converse is FALSE.
But ∠B=∠C, so AB=AC — the triangle is scalene. The converse fails.
IE=IF holds whenever ∠B=∠C or ∠A=60∘. A triangle with angles 60∘,80∘,40∘ has IE=IF yet AB=AC.
If x=y, then a+x=a+y, where x, y and a are any three numbers.
If a and b are perfect squares, then ab is a perfect square.
More counterexamples: (3,12)→36, (5,20)→100, (2,18)→36, (6,24)→144.
x and y are real numbers. If x=y, then x2=y2.
The correct conclusion from x2=y2 is ∣x∣=∣y∣, i.e. x=±y.
x and y are real numbers. If x=y, then x3=y3.
n is a positive integer. If n is divisible by 24, then it is divisible by both 4 and 6.
Others: 36, 60, 84 — every odd multiple of 12.
n is a positive integer. If n is divisible by 60, then it is divisible by both 5 and 12.
n is a positive integer. If n is the square of a prime number, then it has exactly 3 factors.
| Prime p | n=p2 | Factors | Count |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | 4 | 1, 2, 4 | 3 |
| 3 | 9 | 1, 3, 9 | 3 |
| 5 | 25 | 1, 5, 25 | 3 |
| 7 | 49 | 1, 7, 49 | 3 |
n is a positive integer. If n is a product of two unequal prime numbers, then it has exactly 4 divisors.
Also 27=33 with divisors 1,3,9,27, and 125=53 with divisors 1,5,25,125.
Exactly 4 divisors means n=pq (unequal primes) or n=p3.
n is a positive integer. If n and n+3 have no factors in common, then n is not a multiple of 3.
Here "no factors in common" means no common factor other than 1, i.e. gcd(n,n+3)=1.
| n | n+3 | Multiple of 3? | Common factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | 9 | Yes | 3 |
| 9 | 12 | Yes | 3 |
| 7 | 10 | No | none (gcd = 1) |
| 8 | 11 | No | none (gcd = 1) |
| 10 | 13 | No | none (gcd = 1) |
There are no known "neat" expressions that generate only primes. Find counterexamples to the following claims.
(i) All numbers of the form 4n2+1 are prime.
(ii) All numbers of the form n2+n+11 are prime.
(iii) All numbers of the form 4n+3 are prime.
For each one we simply substitute n=1,2,3,… until the result factorises.
(i) 4n2+1
| n | 4n2+1 | Prime? |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4(1)+1=5 | Prime |
| 2 | 4(4)+1=17 | Prime |
| 3 | 4(9)+1=37 | Prime |
| 4 | 4(16)+1=65 | Composite — 65=5×13 |
(ii) n2+n+11
| n | n2+n+11 | Prime? |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1+1+11=13 | Prime |
| 2 | 4+2+11=17 | Prime |
| 5 | 25+5+11=41 | Prime |
| 9 | 81+9+11=101 | Prime |
| 10 | 100+10+11=121 | Composite — 121=112 |
(iii) 4n+3
| n | 4n+3 | Prime? |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4+3=7 | Prime |
| 2 | 16+3=19 | Prime |
| 3 | 64+3=67 | Prime |
| 4 | 256+3=259 | Composite — 259=7×37 |
All three claims are False.
Find counterexamples to the following statements.
(i) If n is a prime number, then 2n−1 is a prime number.
(ii) If n is an even number, then 2n+1 is a prime number.
(i) n prime ⇒2n−1 prime
| prime n | 2n−1 | Prime? |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | 4−1=3 | Prime |
| 3 | 8−1=7 | Prime |
| 5 | 32−1=31 | Prime |
| 7 | 128−1=127 | Prime |
| 11 | 2048−1=2047 | Composite — 2047=23×89 |
(ii) n even ⇒2n+1 prime
| even n | 2n+1 | Prime? |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | 4+1=5 | Prime |
| 4 | 16+1=17 | Prime |
| 6 | 64+1=65 | Composite — 65=5×13 |
Both statements are False.
Consider the statement: "If a number is divisible by 8, then it is divisible by both 2 and 4".
(i) Justify the statement.
(ii) To check whether a given number is divisible by 8, is it enough to check whether it is divisible by 2 and 4? Why or why not?
(i) Justification
(ii) Is checking 2 and 4 enough?
Also n=12,20,28,36 — every number of the form 8k+4.
(ii) No, it is not enough. Checking 2 and 4 only confirms divisibility by LCM(2,4)=4. Counterexample: n=12 passes both tests but is not divisible by 8. Use the last-three-digits rule instead.
A shortcut to check whether a given number is divisible by 3 is to add the digits of the number and check if the sum is a multiple of 3. Express the relationship between "a number is divisible by 3" and "sum of the digits is a multiple of 3" using "if–then" sentences.
| Number | Digit sum | Sum ÷ 3? | Number ÷ 3? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 471 | 4+7+1=12 | Yes | Yes (471=3×157) |
| 5 238 | 5+2+3+8=18 | Yes | Yes (5238=3×1746) |
| 124 | 1+2+4=7 | No | No |
Q (converse): If the sum of the digits of a number is a multiple of 3, then the number is divisible by 3. True
Since both hold, the two statements imply each other — which is precisely what makes the shortcut a valid test.
Suppose we have identified a category of quadrilaterals called Q, and we must construct a quadrilateral of this type using two thin sticks placed as its diagonals, so that joining their endpoints gives a quadrilateral of type Q (see Fig. 9.2).
(i) Suppose Q satisfies: If a quadrilateral is of type Q, then it has equal-length diagonals.
(a) Should the two sticks be of equal length? Why or why not?
(b) Will it matter how the two sticks are put together?
(ii) Instead, suppose Q satisfies: If a quadrilateral has equal diagonals, then it is of type Q. What will be your answers to (a) and (b) now?
The whole question turns on which direction the given "if–then" runs.
Part (i): type Q⇒ equal diagonals
Part (ii): equal diagonals ⇒ type Q
| Given statement | Equal sticks? | Arrangement matters? |
|---|---|---|
| (i) type Q⇒ equal diagonals (necessary) | Yes — required, but not enough | Yes — may still fail |
| (ii) equal diagonals ⇒ type Q (sufficient) | Yes — and it is enough | No — any arrangement works |
(ii) (a) Yes, and equal sticks are now enough to guarantee type Q. (b) No, the arrangement does not matter — any crossing of two equal sticks gives a type-Q quadrilateral.